47) Se7en
Director: David Fincher
Year: 1995
Plot Summary: A deranged serial-killer chooses seven victims who represent egregious examples of transgressions of each of the Seven Deadly Sins. He then views himself as akin to the Sword of God, handing out horrific punishment to these sinners. Two cops, an experienced veteran of the streets who is about to retire and the ambitious young homicide detective hired to replace him, team up to capture the perpetrator of these gruesome killings. Unfortunately, they too become ensnared in his diabolical plan.
Se7en is an infuriating movie. Not in the way that the pretentious Inland Empire or The Science Of Sleep is, but in the sense that it is both breathtaking and disappointing at the same time. While it's a fantastic movie, the infuriating thing about Se7en is that it could have been something spectacular.
Before I go onto that though, it's important to mention just how great the concept of the movie is and how Fincher's style perfectly captures the story. It's very fast paced all the way through and, despite it's long running length, you'll wonder where the time went. Moreover, his brilliant use of colour, lighting, etc. helps to give Se7en an eerie, nightmarish, chilling, grimy atmosphere that complements the narrative spectacularly. It's not got the scope or the ambition of his later work, but it really shows just how talented he is as a director.
Moreover, the use of contrast between the young, naive Mills and the old, cynical Somerset, who are brilliantly captured by Brad Pitt and Morgan Freeman, is something that has always blown me away with Se7en. This contrast is enforced by how Somerset wants to escape from the hellish urban city in which the entire film is set to the countryside. Mills, however, does quite the opposite. Moreover, the contrast of the characters is brilliantly symbolised by the peaceful metronome in Somerset's apartment that helps him switch off to the noise of the city which has corrupted his innocence. It shows that he is used to this place and the evil that lives there. Mills, on the other hand, lives in an apartment right beneath a subway line almost foreshadowing that his naivety about evil - he lives under the impression that everyone who murders like the villain in Se7en is insane, for example - is about to be challenged.
It all sounds brilliant, right? Well, it should be, but like I said... the infuriating Se7en is that it could have been something spectacular, yet it's only something great.
While Andrew Kevin Walker has written a unique and amazing neo-noir narrative which is snappy, has great themes, an impressive structure, etc. his screenplay is let down by the terrible TV soap opera like dialogue. For example, the aforementioned moments in which Mills describes the killer as insane are vital to both his character and the whole idea of Se7en, but surely, Walker could have thought up better lines than "Right now he's probably dancing around in his grandma's panties rubbing peanut butter on himself" and the mocking impression of "The voices made me do it, my dog made me do it, Jodie Foster made me do it!" It's as cringeworthy as something you'd hear in an episode of Miami Vice.
Moreover, while, at times, the characters complement the narrative brilliantly, there are equally as many occasions when they slide into cliche. The way they speak, the whole good cop/bad cop routine and the conventional "why did you become a cop?" and "have you pulled your gun on anyone?" drama finds its way unnecessarily into what is otherwise a daring, edgy thriller that excels everything you'd expect in the police genre.
Lastly, Se7en is almost completely ruined with the far too predictable ending. Sure, it works with what the film-makers are trying to achieve, but because you've guessed it minutes before it happens, you are spared the gut-punching effect it should have.
By no means is it a bad movie - for a police story it's one of the best you'll find from this generation of cinema - but with a little bit of work, this could have been a masterpiece. One thing is for certain though, if there's one person to thank for this brilliant piece of work it's David Fincher because Se7en wouldn't have been this good in anyone else's hands.
4/5